Best Meal Replacement Shakes

Seniors and their caregivers who are looking for convenient food options frequently choose meal replacement shakes.

A protein-enriched shake can be an excellent source of essential vitamins and minerals that requires little to no preparation time and is easier to ingest than some regular food. 

Seniors need a nutrition-rich diet, and shakes can provide added nutrients without added work.

What Is a Meal Replacement Shake?

Meal replacement shakes are processed drinks consumed as a substitute for a standard meal of solid food. Most shakes have measured levels of nutrients, vitamins, minerals, or calories and are often used to support either weight loss or weight gain efforts. 

Since seniors require a diet rich in proteins and vitamins B12, D, and calcium, they often use shakes as a dietary aid to ensure they get the right levels of nutrients.

Before adding protein shakes into the diet, consult with a physician. Added levels of protein or other nutrients can cause adverse effects when combined with certain medications and medical conditions.

How Do Meal Replacement Shakes Help To Lose Weight in the Elderly?

For seniors who need to lose weight because of heart conditions or other issues, a low-carb meal replacement shake can help jump-start weight loss. Some studies have found that those who drank meal replacement shakes for weight loss experienced better results than those who did not.

The additional protein contained in the shakes can help satisfy hunger pangs. Seniors may also find that diet shakes are more convenient and shelf-stable than other types of diet food.

How Do Protein Meal Replacement Shakes Help To Gain Weight in the Elderly?

A person’s weight is affected by the number of calories burned compared to the calories eaten. People trying to gain weight must take in more calories than are being used by the body throughout the day. 

Experts have recommended that older people consume .45 to .6 grams of protein per pound of body weight. Meal replacement shakes can be an easy way to add caloric intake.

Meal Replacement Shakes vs. Protein Smoothies and Shakes

While meal replacement shakes are commonly called protein shakes, not all protein smoothies or shakes can take the place of a full meal from a nutritional standpoint. Although they contain similar ingredients, there are also important differences.

NameMeal Replacement ShakesMeal Replacement Shakes
CaloriesOften 250 to 400Often less than 150
Protein contentTypically between 9 to 40 grams100-110Typically between 25 grams or more
CarbohydratesVaries depending on intended use from 3 to over 30 gramsTypically less than 5 grams
Fat contentDepends on carbohydrate levels, as shakes with high-fat content typically have lower carbohydrates, and vice versaNormally 3 grams or fewer
Vitamins and mineralsFrequently a high percentage of daily requirementsUsually, only those Provided by the source of protein

Meal Replacement Shakes vs. Meal Replacement Bars

Both meal replacement shakes and bars can provide additional nutrition. For those trying to lose weight, the bar typically keeps a person feeling full longer than a shake. For many seniors, however, shakes are easier to ingest. Bars should be eaten in combination with drinking a glass of water.

Top 10 Meal Replacement Shakes and Powders

While meal replacement shakes should not be used to replace all meals, they make a useful alternative for some throughout the day.

When evaluating which is the best shake, several criteria can be used, including quality ingredients, convenience, nutritional value, taste, price, and customer satisfaction ratings.

Many of the best shakes are available for purchase online.

1. Ensure Original Nutritional Shake

Ensure Original Nutrition Shake with 9 grams of protein, Meal Replacement Shakes, Milk Chocolate, 8 fl oz, 16 Count

Buy on Amazon

Feel more strength and energy in as little as two Comes in convenient 8-ounce or compact 4-ounce bottles with six flavors to choose from. Also available with higher protein content or in powdered form.

Gluten-free, kosher, halal, and acceptable for individuals with lactose intolerance. Do not drink if you have galactosemia. Ensure claims to be the number-one doctor-recommended brand.

Nutrition From Ensure Original Nutritional Shake

Has 220 calories and contains 9 grams of protein, 6 grams of fat, 33 grams of carbohydrates, 15 grams of sugar, 1 gram of fiber and antioxidants, including vitamins C and E

Cost Range

Just over $1 per serving.

Customer Reviews

Most customers described enjoying the taste and consistency. They also reported boosted levels of energy and being able to retain or gain weight.

Sale
Ensure Original Nutrition Shake with 9 grams of protein, Meal Replacement Shakes, Milk Chocolate, 8 fl oz, 16 Count
  • COMPLETE, BALANCED NUTRITION: Each shake has 220 calories, 9g of high-quality protein, & provides complete and balanced nutrition
  • IMMUNE SYSTEM SUPPORT: Contains 80% daily value of Vitamin C and 40% daily value Vitamin D
  • No:1 DOCTOR-RECOMMENDED: Ensure is the #1 doctor-recommended nutrition drink brand
  • 1 DOCTOR-RECOMMENDED: Ensure is the #1 doctor-recommended nutrition drink brand
  • DAILY USE: Enjoy Ensure as a small meal replacement, with a meal, or as a delicious snack to help maintain proper nutrition

Buy on Amazon

2. Labrada Lean Body

Lean Body Ready-to-Drink Vanilla Protein Shake, 40g Protein, Whey Blend, 0 Sugar, Gluten Free, 22 Vitamins & Minerals, (Recyclable Carton & Lid - Pack of 12) LABRADA

Buy on Amazon

Ready-to-drink and packaged in a portable container that travels conveniently with you. Low-calorie and free of sugar, gluten and Helps build a fit, healthy and lean body. No powder or mixing is required, with nine flavors to choose from.

Nutrition From Labrada Lean Body

Has 280 calories and contains 40 grams of high-quality whey protein, milk protein and soy lecithin, 9 grams of carbohydrates, 0 grams of sugar, 5 grams of fiber and 22 vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

12-pack of 17-ounce bottles runs around $35 to $40, or approximately $3 per serving, and is considered one of the more expensive options.

Customer Reviews

Many customers described how they liked one or more of the product’s flavors, although the sweetener may be overpowering to some. Although the product claims to have no lactose, some customers recommend that those with lactose intolerance avoid this product.

Lean Body Ready-to-Drink Vanilla Protein Shake, 40g Protein, Whey Blend, 0 Sugar, Gluten Free, 22 Vitamins & Minerals, (Recyclable Carton & Lid - Pack of 12) LABRADA
  • Get 40g of protein on-the-go: forget time-consuming meal prep and counting food protein content. With labrada’s lean Body ready-to-drink protein shake you get a whopping 40g of protein in one tasty drink! Just enjoy your shake and imagine how each creamy, delicious sip will bring you closer to achieving your fitness goals and attaining the lean Body of your dreams. Choose between our 8 Available Flavors – or try them all to find your new, lifelong favorite RTD protein shake!
  • Boost your metabolism & curb sugar cravings: labrada’s lean Body ready-to-drink protein shake makes you feel fuller for a longer period of time, allowing you to better manage your weight. Jammed packed with protein and fiber, our drink also helps boost your metabolism, curb those pesky sugar and junk food cravings and keep you on track with maintaining a healthy diet. And, since protein is the building block of muscles, each lean Body protein shake is a true investment towards making those gains!
  • Well-rounded meal replacement with 22 vitamins & minerals: perfect as a pre- or post-workout snack, Our lean Body ready-to-drink protein shake is also a wholesome meal in and of itself! It contains 22 vitamins and minerals, including, but not limited to, Vitamin A; vitamin E; Biotin; Riboflavin; potassium; magnesium and zinc! Our drink is a nutritional powerhouse that helps your body recover from exercise, all while aiding in fighting any deficiencies that might be bringing your energy levels down!
  • Gluten and sugar-free protein drink: Our protein shake is formulated without gluten and sugar, making it ideal for those with allergies and food sensitivities. What's more, Contrary to other PROTEIN shakes on the market, Our drink is also free of soy protein, which studies have shown to be a very controversial food source. So chug away knowing you’ve made the best meal replacement choice with labrada’s lean Body ready-to-drink protein shake!
  • Labrada’s science-backed seal of quality: with over 20 years of experience in developing advanced sports supplements, we have created an elite product range that is trusted by professional athletes, nutrition specialists and people like you who wish to improve their fitness and dietary regimens. Our strict third-party testing, potent ingredients and exclusive formulas are the reasons for our success, and we are happy to share it with you! Click add to Cart now and feel the difference yourself!

Buy on Amazon

3. MET-Rx Original Meal Replacement

MET-Rx Meal Replacement Powder Boxed, Extreme Chocolate, 2.54 Oz, Pack of 40

Buy on Amazon

Available in single-serving powder packets or ready-to-serve bottles. Provides the protein and carbs needed to support energy levels during rest and activities throughout the day. Low-fat and aspartame-free; mix with milk or water. Available in vanilla and extreme chocolate. Not intended for weight reduction.

Nutrition From Rx Original Meal Replacement

Has 240 calories and contains 38 grams of Metamyosyn protein blend combined with slow-acting casein with milk protein, 90 percent DV of calcium for bone health, 3 grams of L-Glutamine amino acid, over 6 grams of BCAAs, 17-20 grams of carbohydrates, 3 grams of fiber, 2 grams of sugar and 25 essential vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

40 servings range from $59 to $70, or around $1.50 to $1.75 per serving.

Customer Reviews

Most customers enjoyed the taste and recommended experimenting with water or milk levels to reach the desired consistency. People felt full after drinking the serving-sized Studies are still underway regarding the effects of casein.

MET-Rx Meal Replacement Powder Boxed, Extreme Chocolate, 2.54 Oz, Pack of 40
  • One 40 count box of MET-Rx Meal Replacement Extreme Chocolate Protein Powder packets
  • MET-Rx utilizes state-of-the-art manufacturing techniques to offer an ultra-filtered chocolate whey protein powder
  • Easy to mix protein supplement powder is ideal for meal replacement shakes, protein smoothies and other protein drinks
  • Gluten free protein powder contains 36 grams of protein per serving, 3 grams of L-glutamine and over 7 grams of BCCAs from protein
  • MET-Rx protein drinks are convenient for pre workout or post workout shakes

Buy on Amazon

4. IdealShake by IdealShape

IdealShake Meal Replacement Shakes |11-12g of Healthy Whey Protein Blend | Promotes Weight Loss | 22 Essential Vitamins & Minerals | 5g of Fiber | Chocolate Cream Pie | 30 Servings

Buy on Amazon

Contains a powerful, all-natural potato protein hunger-blocker to help with weight loss. The sweet, creamy taste pleases the sweet tooth. Use the powder to whip up a shake in just seconds. This low-fat, aspartame-free shake controls hunger for up to three hours and offers several flavors to choose from.

Nutrition From IdealShake

Contains 11-12 grams of whey protein balanced with 3 grams of fat and 10 grams of carbohydrates for faster weight loss. Also contains 2 grams or less of sugar and 5 grams of fiber, plus vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

With 30 servings costing approximately $50, or around $1.67 each, this is considered a less expensive alternative than some other comparable shakes.

Customer Reviews

Some customers complained of stomach pain or bloating for the first few days after using this product. Many confirmed they enjoyed the taste and their hunger was controlled. California containers display a warning that they may contain lead.

IdealShake Meal Replacement Shakes |11-12g of Healthy Whey Protein Blend | Promotes Weight Loss | 22 Essential Vitamins & Minerals | 5g of Fiber | Chocolate Cream Pie | 30 Servings
  • LOW FAT + LOW SUGAR: If you are craving a smooth and creamy meal replacement with only 110-120 calories and 2g of sugar, our mouth-watering protein powder is exactly what you need!
  • PROMOTES LEAN MUSCLE MASS: 11g of whey protein in every tasty serving combined with daily exercise will help increase fat burn and post workout muscle recovery.
  • VITAMINS AND MINERALS: Our meal replacement powder is packed with 22 vitamins, minerals and 5g of dietary fiber.
  • FEEL MORE ENERGIZED, STRONGER & HEALTHIER – With the right balance of protein, carbs, and fat, just pick a delicious flavor of our meal replacement shake and mix in your favorite ingredients to keep you satisfied!
  • QUICK AND EASY - IdealShake is easy to use and easy to make. Replace one or two meals a day for safe and effective weight loss. Whip up a meal replacement shake in seconds! It's the perfect grab-and-go diet shake.

Buy on Amazon

5. Garden of Life Raw Organic Meal

Garden of Life Vegan Protein Powder - Raw Organic Meal Replacement Shakes - Vanilla - Pea Protein, Greens and Probiotics for Women and Men, Plant Based Dairy Free All in One Shake, 28 Servings

Buy on Amazon

This powder provides all the protein, fiber, vitamins, and minerals found in a healthy meal of raw foods. Contains no tree nuts, gluten, soy, dairy, artificial sweeteners, filler ingredients, or preservatives.

It is kosher, vegan, Informed Choice Certified has non-GMO whole food protein, plus it’s tasty and smooth, with four flavors to choose from.

Nutrition From Garden of LifeRaw Organic Meal

With 115 calories, this shake is packed with 21 vitamins and minerals, 20 grams of clean, organic plant protein, 6 grams of fiber, 8 grams of carbohydrates, less than 1 gram of sugar, 44 superfoods, including fruits, vegetables and organic grass juices, and probiotics and enzymes for easy digestion.

Cost Range

Considered affordable at just over $1 to $1.42 per ounce depending on the quantity purchased.

Customer Reviews

While mostly positive, some customers felt the powder had a distinctive taste that was better when blended with almond milk or fruit.

Many recommended drinking immediately to avoid warming and thickening or adding more water than recommended for a smoother drinking consistency.

Sale
Garden of Life Vegan Protein Powder - Raw Organic Meal Replacement Shakes - Vanilla - Pea Protein, Greens and Probiotics for Women and Men, Plant Based Dairy Free All in One Shake, 28 Servings
  • ON THE GO NUTRITION: 20 grams of clean, organic plant protein with 44 superfoods including organic grass juices, fruits and veggies and fiber to keep you satisfied
  • POST WORKOUT RECOVERY: Help build lean muscle and boost energy with this power packed meal replacement.Does Not Contain Any of the 8 Major Allergens
  • VITAMINS AND MINERALS: This delicious vanilla protein powder is packed with 21 vitamins and minerals
  • MEAL REPLACEMENT SHAKE WITH PROBIOTICS: Tasty, smooth protein shake with 1.5 billion CFU probiotics and enzymes for easy digestion
  • VEGAN PROTEIN POWDER: Organic, gluten free, Kosher, vegan, dairy free, soy free, Informed Choice Certified (Trusted by Sport), non GMO whole food protein

Buy on Amazon

6. Orgain Organic Protein Shake

Orgain Organic 26g Grass Fed Whey Protein Shake, Creamy Chocolate - Meal Replacement, Ready to Drink, Low Net Carbs, No Sugar Added, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, 14 Ounce, 12 Count (Packaging May Vary)

Buy on Amazon

Ready-to-drink and packaged in a portable container that travels conveniently with you. Low-calorie and free of sugar, gluten and Helps build a fit, healthy and lean body. No powder or mixing is required, with nine flavors to choose from.

Nutrition From Orgain Organic Protein Shake

Has 280 calories and contains 40 grams of high-quality whey protein, milk protein and soy lecithin, 9 grams of carbohydrates, 0 grams of sugar, 5 grams of fiber and 22 vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

12-pack of 17-ounce bottles runs around $35 to $40, or approximately $3 per serving, and is considered one of the more expensive options.

Customer Reviews

Many customers described how they liked one or more of the product’s flavors, although the sweetener may be overpowering to some. Although the product claims to have no lactose, some customers recommend that those with lactose intolerance avoid this product.

Orgain Organic 26g Grass Fed Whey Protein Shake, Creamy Chocolate - Meal Replacement, Ready to Drink, Low Net Carbs, No Sugar Added, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, 14 Ounce, 12 Count (Packaging May Vary)
  • Includes 12 (14oz) ready to drink Orgain Organic Creamy Chocolate Nutritional Protein Shakes.
  • 26 grams of clean organic grass fed milk protein and whey protein, 3 grams of net carbs, 1 gram of naturally occuring sugar, 150 calories per serving
  • USDA organic, gluten free, vegetarian friendly, no added sugar, soy free, kosher, non-GMO, carrageenan free. Diabetic friendly. No artifical colors, flavors, or preservatives.
  • A perfect way to supplement protein in your diet and reduce cravings and hunger. 90% of daily recommended calcium in this one shake!
  • Ideal for healthy, on-the-go nutrition for men and women. These are great for meal replacement, a quick breakfast or snack, weight management (weight gain or loss), building lean muscle, muscle recovery, and pre or post workouts.

Buy on Amazon

7. ​GNC Lean Shake

GNC Total Lean Rich Chocolate Shake 29.3 oz - 25 Grams of Protein

Buy on Amazon

Available in either ready-to-drink bottles or powder. Fuels a healthy metabolism with fiber that helps you feel full. Supports lean muscle tone and healthy blood sugar levels while substituting as a low-carb meal replacement shake. Over 10 flavors to choose from.

Nutrition From GNC Lean Shake

Has 200 calories and contains 25 grams of high-quality protein, 8 grams of fiber, 17 grams of carbohydrates, 3-4 grams of sugar, 3 grams of fat and 24 vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

Powder costs approximately $40 for a 1.83-pound, 16-serving container, or about $2.50 per serving.

Customer Reviews

Reviews on taste range from “most delicious” to “awful,” so it may depend on how the user mixes the product.

GNC Total Lean Rich Chocolate Shake 29.3 oz - 25 Grams of Protein
  • Healthy meal replacement to support lean muscle tone and a healthy metabolism

Buy on Amazon

8. Soylent Meal Replacement Powder

Soylent Complete Nutrition Gluten-Free Vegan Protein Meal Replacement Powder, Original, 36.8 Oz

Buy on Amazon

Powder delivers complete, convenient meals that are intended to substitute for food. Two scoops of powder can be mixed with water or one scoop added to smoothies or protein drinks for additional nutrition. Also available in ready-to-drink shakes or powder packets, it is gluten-free, dairy-free and entirely

Nutrition From Soylent Meal Replacement Powder

Has 400 calories per two-scoop serving and contains 20 grams of protein, including protein from soy, 41 grams of carbohydrates, including slow-burning carbs from beets, 20 grams of fat, 15 grams of sugar, 6 grams of fiber, 25 micronutrients and all essential vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

A can of 12 servings (24 scoops) of powder costs between $32 to $34, or $2.60 to $2.90 per serving.

Customer Reviews

Comments about the flavor ranged from positive to negative, depending on taste. Some felt the sugar content was too high and the powder must be well-mixed with enough liquid to minimize a pancake-batter consistency or chalky texture.

Soylent Complete Nutrition Gluten-Free Vegan Protein Meal Replacement Powder, Original, 36.8 Oz
  • Includes: 1 36.8-oz. Soylent original (plain, cereal milk flavor) plant-based complete meal replacement protein powder
  • Complete Nutrition: Enjoy a quick, convenient, rich and creamy meal replacement and nutritional supplement; Soylent's nutrient-dense protein shakes provide the vitamins, minerals, healthy fats, and carbohydrates your body needs to thrive
  • 20g Complete Plant-Based Vegan Protein: Contains all 9 essential amino acids with 3.5g BCAAs (Branched Chain Amino Acids) that help support lean muscle mass maintenance, strength, energy, and satiety to keep you going
  • 39 Essential Nutrients: A great tasting way to get 28 vitamins and minerals, 9 amino acids, and 2 healthy fats omega-3 and omega-6 for complete daily nutrition, antioxidant, immune, and heart health support
  • Dietary Friendly Formula: 330mg Omega-3 and slow-burning carbs; Gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free, vegan, and kosher

Buy on Amazon

9. Advocare Meal Replacement Shake

Powder is available in single-serving pouches. Shakes are formulated for enhanced nutrient absorption and are easy to digest.

Nutrition From Advocare Meal Replacement Shake

Has 220 calories and contains 24 grams of protein and carbohydrates per serving with a one-to-one protein-to-carbohydrate ratio, plus 3 grams of fat, 12 grams of sugar and 6 grams of fiber.

Cost Range

A 14-pack ranges from $43 to $49, or between $3 and $3.50 per serving, and is considered one of the pricier alternatives.

Customer Reviews

Some customers reported abdominal pains after drinking. May need extra liquid for a smoother consistency. Others recommended blending with ice cream or fruit.

10. SlimFast

SlimFast Meal Replacement Shake, Original French Vanilla, 10g of Ready to Drink Protein for Weight Loss, 11 Fl. Oz Bottle, 8 Count (Pack of 3)

Buy on Amazon

Available in either ready-to-drink bottles or powder. With four-hour hunger control, one 11-ounce, gluten-free drink contains one-third of the recommended daily nutritional intake. Multiple flavors

Nutrition From Slimfast

Has 180 calories and contains 10 grams of protein, 5 grams of fiber, 18 grams of sugar, 24 grams of carbohydrates, 6 grams of fat and 24 essential vitamins and minerals.

Cost Range

The 24 pack of 11-ounce bottles range from $41 to $45, or $1.70 to $1.90 per serving.

Customer Reviews

Received the Chef’s Best Taste Award in addition to multiple awards from Men’s Health and OK! Magazine. Many customers claim they lose weight while replacing one or two meals with this shake and eating a healthy third meal.

Sale
SlimFast Meal Replacement Shake, Original French Vanilla, 10g of Ready to Drink Protein for Weight Loss, 11 Fl. Oz Bottle, 8 Count (Pack of 3)
  • A taste you'll love - Delightfully creamy French Vanilla flavor
  • Created with your nutrition in mind by providing 24 vitamins and minerals like A, C, D, E and Zinc
  • Each delicious shake provides up to four hours of hunger control to keep you on track
  • Each SlimFast Original Shake provides 10g of protein, 5g of fiber and only 180 calories
  • Not a low calorie food. See Nutrition Facts for saturated fat content.

Buy on Amazon

Best Meal Replacement Shake for Men

For the best meal replacement shake for men, the recommendation goes to Labrada Lean Body. It contains both fast- and slow-release proteins to help sustain energy. On multiple occasions, Labrada won the Gold Medal Taste Award from the American Culinary Institute.

 Its high-quality rating comes with a moderately high price. This healthy meal replacement shake can be used for either gaining or losing weight depending on other food choices.

Best Meal Replacement Shake for Women

Ensure ranks on top as the best replacement shake for women. There are multiple flavors to choose from, the mixture contains no harmful ingredients, and many people report enjoying the taste. 

There are different formulas depending on the intended use, including either losing or gaining weight. The price is considered moderate and depends on whether purchases are made individually or in bulk quantities.

Best Meal Replacement Shakes for Weight Loss

IdealShake by IdealShape ranks as one of the best meal replacement shakes for weight loss, as long as you are willing to mix up shakes for each meal. Hunger pangs can be the biggest enemy of weight loss, and the all-natural hunger blocker has been reported to control hunger for hours. 

Customers also made positive reports about the taste, and shake preparation is quick and easy.

For those who want a premixed, ready-to-drink shake, the top choice is GNC Lean Shake. Many customers enjoyed the taste of this low-carb meal replacement shake. Its fiber helps seniors feel fuller for a more extended period.

Best Meal Replacement Shakes for Weight Gain

For those who are trying to gain or maintain weight, one of the top meal replacement shakes is Ensure. Customers report gaining and maintaining weight levels while substituting these nutritious shakes for one or two meals per day. It comes in multiple serving sizes, flavors, and varieties. 

In a survey of 321 seniors ranging from 50 to 80 years old who reported lacking energy or appetite, participants self-reported improvements in activity, strength, and energy after adding one to two servings of Ensure per day.

Meal Replacement Shakes To Avoid

While Soylent meal replacement powder is considered healthy, seniors may want to be careful when drinking the café varieties that contain caffeine. MET-Rx shakes contain casein, a protein derived from cow’s milk that has been shown to cause tumor growth in some studies; however, other studies refute this finding.

Those with diabetes should carefully review the sugar content when choosing a brand, like Ensure, Advocare, Soylent, and SlimFast range from 12 to 18 grams of sugar per serving.

Conclusion

Meal replacement shakes often become a valuable part of a senior’s diet. As the desire to make meals changes and the ability to ingest heavy meals or hard-to-eat foods diminishes, healthy meal replacement shakes can make up for nutrient deficiencies.

Added nutrition can also help battle osteoporosis, or brittle and fragile bones, and sarcopenia, a reduction in muscle mass, which can become serious problems the older one gets.

While being convenient to make or take with you, shakes also provide an easy way to measure daily nutrition and calories. Depending on the intended use, shakes can curb appetite, help maintain or gain weight, boost energy or supplement nutritional intake.

Leave a Comment